Saturday, July 31, 2004

"This is like the pope coming out in favor of abortion rights."

That's what ACLU board member Wendy Kaminer said about the civil liberties group's decision to refuse to hire those on terrorist "watch lists"--the very lists that the ACLU itself has called unconstitutional.

As for the decision itself, I'm a little surprised. Even though the ACLU caved anticommunism in 1940 with the outser of Elizabeth Gurley Flynn and other communists, the organization has admirably stuck to its guns since then. Even when I've disagreed with them, for example when they filed an amicus brief on behalf of Little Mussolini in his prescription drug case, or, more seriously, when they've argued that corporations have the right to lie about their labor practices, I've got to give them credit for being principled. Until now.

As for Kaminer, I'll give her credit for knowing how to turn a phrase. A contributing editor at the Atlantic (even though she hasn't written anything for them since 1999), she's the origin of the line: "A liberal is a conservative who's been arrested. A conservative is a liberal who's been mugged."

OUT: "negativity"

IN: "red meat"


At August 3, 2004 at 12:16 AM, Blogger Dan said...

Lising on the masthead contributing editors who don't actually contribute seems to be somewhat common in the magazine industry. The liberal New Republic's masthead includes Michael Kinsley, who hasn't written anything for them in ages.


Post a Comment

<< Home